DMARC platform comparison

dmarcian vs Valimail: read-only reports or automated, hosted records?

Both turn DMARC aggregate reports into named sending sources and guide you toward p=reject. dmarcian is read-only by design and sells people to help with deployment. Valimail hosts your DMARC, SPF and DKIM records and automates the path to enforcement, with a free reporting tier and a self-serve plan billed per domain per year.

Which one fits you?

choose dmarcian if
  • You want forensic (RUF) reports on a self-serve plan: Basic includes them from $24/mo, where Valimail's opt-in RUF+ is on Enforce Enterprise only.
  • You want people to take you to p=reject: dmarcian sells a dedicated Deployment Manager and tiered support contracts.
  • You want a monthly price you can buy online: Basic is $24/mo for 2 domains and 100,000 messages, or $19.99/mo billed yearly, where Valimail Essentials is billed a year at a time.
choose Valimail if
  • You want your DMARC data for free across all of your domains: Monitor needs no card and emails a weekly report, though the guided path to p=reject starts on Essentials.
  • You want the records hosted: DMARC by NS or CNAME, Instant SPF to stay under the 10-lookup limit, and hosted DKIM. dmarcian hosts no records.
  • You want a guided path from p=none to p=reject with instant rollback, self-serve: Essentials is $250 per domain per year for up to 5 domains.
or consider Unspam if
  • You want to pay per domain each month: $6 per domain, the first domain included, up to 500 domains in one account.
  • You want a per-domain readiness check that lists what still blocks p=quarantine or p=reject, without a deployment service or an annual contract.
  • Skip it if you need hosted records, forensic reports or alerts: Unspam reads aggregate reports only.

dmarcian vs Valimail, feature by feature.

Rows from each vendor's public pricing and product pages, with Unspam alongside for reference.

  • Included
  • Partly or with limits
  • Not offered
Feature
dmarcian
Valimail
Unspam
Free plan or trial
Personal: free for non-business use, 2 domains, 1,250 emails/mo
Monitor: free reporting, no card, guided enforcement on paid tiers
First domain free on the Custom plan
First paid plan
$24/mo (Basic), or $19.99/mo billed yearly
$250 per domain per year (Essentials)
$5/mo Custom plan minimum, then $6 per domain per month
Aggregate (RUA) report monitoring
Yes
Yes
Yesfirst domain free
Sending sources named and classified
Yesnamed sources on every plan
Yes
YesESP, own, forwarder, spoofing
Guidance to p=reject
Yesremediation guidance, paid deployment
YesEnforce and Essentials, not Monitor
Yespolicy readiness checks
Failure (RUF) reports
YesBasic and up, not Personal
Partialopt-in RUF+, Enterprise only
No
Hosted DMARC record
Noread-only by design
YesEssentials and Enforce, NS or CNAME
No
Hosted SPF / SPF flattening
Nodeclines SPF flattening; SPF Surveyor
YesInstant SPF on Essentials and Enforce
No
Hosted DKIM
NoDKIM inspection only
YesNS delegation on Enforce; hosted on Essentials
No
BIMI
PartialInspector, Builder, SVG Validator
YesAmplify add-on; hosted in Essentials
Partialchecked in spam tests
MTA-STS / TLS reporting
PartialTLS-RPT on every plan, MTA-STS inspection only
YesMTA-STS hosting on Enforce only
No
Alerts
YesBasic: invalid and warnings only; full set from Plus
Yesemail alerts on Monitor; webhooks on Enforce
No
Scheduled email reports
Yesscheduled daily, weekly or monthly
Yesweekly on Monitor; executive reports on Enforce
Yesweekly, every Monday
API access
YesEnterprise only
Yesadd-on, included on Enterprise
YesCustom plan
MCP server
No
No
YesCustom plan
MSP / multi-tenant
YesMSP Portal, partner pricing on request
YesDMARC Core and DMARC Pro, Pax8
Partialup to 500 domains in one account
Managed enforcement service
YesDeployment Manager, support tiers
Partialpaid Valicare support, TAM on Valicare+
No
Pre-send email testing
No
No
Yesspam score, placement, previews, verification

Both checked November 2026, from their public pricing and product pages.

What each one costs.

dmarcian

Personal
$0
Basic
$24/mo billed monthly, or $19.99/mo billed yearly ($239.88/year)
Plus
$240/mo billed monthly, or $199/mo billed yearly ($2,388/year)
Enterprise
$600/mo billed monthly, or $499/mo billed yearly ($5,988/year)
Custom
Tailored pricing
dmarcian pricing in detail

Valimail

Monitor
Free
Essentials
$250/year/domain up to 100,000 emails/month, $450/year/domain up to 500,000
Enforce Starter
Contact us for custom pricing
Enforce Premium
Contact us for custom pricing
Enforce Enterprise
Contact us for custom pricing
Amplify
Contact us for pricing
Valimail pricing in detail

Where they differ.

01

Hosted records

Valimail can host your DMARC record by NS or CNAME, keep SPF under the 10-lookup limit with Instant SPF and host DKIM, so a policy change happens in its dashboard rather than in your DNS. dmarcian is read-only by design: it inspects your records and tells you what to change, and you edit DNS yourself.

02

How the price is set

dmarcian prices tiers by active domains and monthly messages: Basic covers 2 domains and 100,000 messages for $24/mo, and a third active domain moves you to Plus at $240/mo. Valimail's Monitor is free, Essentials is $250 per domain per year up to 100,000 emails a month and $450 up to 500,000, for up to 5 domains, and Enforce is quoted.

03

Help getting to p=reject

dmarcian sells deployment as a service, with a Deployment Manager and support tiers. Valimail automates it: Essentials and Enforce walk a domain from p=none to p=quarantine to p=reject with instant rollback, and paid Valicare support adds people on top.

dmarcian vs Valimail, answered.

Is dmarcian or Valimail cheaper?
For seeing your data, Valimail: Monitor is free, with no card, across your domains. For a paid plan on 2 domains, dmarcian Basic is $24/mo, or $19.99/mo billed yearly, against $500 a year on Valimail Essentials at $250 per domain. From a third domain, dmarcian moves to Plus at $240/mo, while Essentials adds $250 a year per domain, up to 5.
Do dmarcian and Valimail host DMARC records?
Valimail does, on Essentials and Enforce, by NS or CNAME, along with SPF and DKIM. dmarcian does not: it is read-only by design and leaves DNS changes to you. Unspam hosts no records either; it reads aggregate reports and checks readiness for enforcement.
Can Unspam replace dmarcian or Valimail?
For reading aggregate reports and naming your sending sources, yes, at $6 per domain per month with the first domain included. For hosted records, forensic reports, alerts or a team to take you to p=reject, no: Unspam is self-serve and reads aggregate reports only.

Each one against Unspam

dmarcian and Valimail are trademarks of their respective owners. Unspam is not affiliated with or endorsed by either.

Add your first domain free and read your first reports in about two days.