ARC: a Finished Experiment You Were Never Meant to Deploy

If you are an ordinary sender and a guide has told you to deploy ARC, that guide is wrong twice over. ARC is something an intermediary adds while relaying somebody else's message, so an originating sender has nothing to seal. And the IETF working group that owns it published a draft in April 2026 asking for the specification to be reclassified as Historic, on the grounds that the experiment is finished, and re-posted it with the same text on 21 October 2026.

None of which makes ARC useless to read. It still explains why a forwarded message was delivered or refused, and two mailbox providers, Apple and Orange, still ask forwarders for it. Reading it and deploying it are different decisions, and only one of them is being retired.

ARC records what a forwarder saw, which is why a sender has nothing to seal

DMARC breaks on forwarding. A mailing list or a forwarding address relays your message from its own servers, so SPF fails on an envelope domain that is not yours, and any modification to the headers or body breaks your DKIM signature. The message was legitimate when you sent it and fails authentication when it arrives.

ARC was the proposed answer. Each intermediary records the authentication results it saw on arrival, signs that record, and seals the chain of everything before it. A receiver at the end can then see the original result as the first hop observed it, even though the evidence itself is gone.

The party doing that signing is the forwarder, not you. You publish nothing for ARC, there is no DNS record for it on your domain beyond the DKIM key an intermediary would use if you happened to be one, and the header set appears only on messages that have been relayed. A guide that tells an ordinary sending domain to "enable ARC" has confused it with DKIM.

The chain is three headers per hop, and the numbering is the check

Each hop adds three headers, and RFC 8617 section 5.2 makes the set and the sequence strict.

HeaderWhat it carries
ARC-Authentication-ResultsThe authentication results this hop saw on arrival
ARC-Message-SignatureA signature over the message as this hop received it
ARC-SealA signature over the chain so far, carrying the chain validation status

Four rules turn those headers into a chain rather than a pile:

  • Instance numbers run from 1 upward, continuously, to a maximum of 50. A gap or a repetition is a malformed chain, not a chain with a missing link.
  • Each instance has exactly one of each of the three headers. A duplicate is a fault.
  • The seal at instance 1 must carry cv=none, and every later instance must carry cv=pass. That value is the signer's statement about everything before it.
  • A cv=fail at the highest instance ends the chain there. Once a hop records a failure, nothing after it restores the chain.

The structure is checkable offline and the signatures are not, which is the entire shape of what any header tool can honestly tell you. A reader that looks at the highest instance and reports the value it finds has skipped the check that matters, because it is the continuity from 1 that makes the sequence meaningful.

The IETF is retiring ARC, and says so in plain language

draft-ietf-dmarc-arc-to-historic-01, posted on 21 October 2026 by Trent Adams of Proofpoint and John Levine of Taughannock Networks, is a document of the IETF DMARC working group, not an individual proposal. Its first version was approved as a working group draft on 22 April 2026. It obsoletes RFC 8617 if approved and asks that the specification be marked Historic.

Its conclusions are unusually direct. The experiment is over. Implementers and operators should not rely on ARC going forward and should cease further Internet-wide deployments. Existing deployers should plan to decommission or confine their use to controlled, intra-domain contexts. New deployments are discouraged because they are unlikely to provide useful information for mail processing. Receivers that still parse ARC may keep verifying it for forensic or intra-domain purposes, but should not base delivery decisions on chain validity without robust reputation signals.

The reason given is not that the cryptography failed. It is that verification without reputation cannot safely override an enforcement policy. An evaluator has to decide whether to trust each signer in the chain before acting on its assertions, which means running a reputation system for intermediaries, and after ten years nobody built one that works at Internet scale. What deployers built instead were allowlists of intermediaries they already trusted, which works bilaterally and does not generalize. The draft names this the core lesson: signatures are not trust.

A second limitation is more specific. When an intermediary modifies a message, ARC identifies who modified it but has no mechanism to say what was changed or why, so the receiver is back to judging the intermediary's reputation. The useful pieces are being folded into the DKIM successor work currently called DKIM2, which avoids a parallel chain and a separate hop-by-hop trust fabric.

The draft gives two more reasons. Forwarding is still the dominant cause of breakage, and forwarders are too numerous and change too often to enumerate. And receivers never agreed on how many hops to honor, how to treat a partial or broken chain, or when ARC could influence DMARC enforcement, so the same message could be judged differently from one receiver to the next.

Where the retirement stands in November 2026

The draft is a working group document, not a decision. Revision -01, posted on 21 October 2026, changes only its dates: the text is the same as the April version, which was due to expire on 24 October 2026, and the new expiry is 24 April 2027. The datatracker records no working group last call, no IETF last call and no document shepherd. The DMARC working group's charter carries one milestone, dated 30 November 2026: request approval of a status-change document moving ARC to Historic.

If that request is approved, RFC 8617 is reclassified as Historic, the status the IETF gives a specification it considers obsolete. The RFC stays published and existing implementations keep working, but the specification stops being an experiment anyone is invited to join. Until then ARC is still an Experimental RFC, and the draft is work in progress. What it documents, though, is not a proposal so much as a description of where effort has already stopped.

Apple and Orange still ask for ARC, and both ask the forwarder

Apple's sender requirements, published in February 2025, ask for ARC on forwarded mail to Apple mailboxes. It is the only one of the four large providers to ask for it at all. Orange's postmaster page, updated on 1 September 2026, lists SPF, DKIM and DMARC as required and strongly recommends ARC sealing for forwarded messages. Those two asks are the honest reason to surface ARC in a checker rather than ignore it.

Read the scope carefully, because it is where this gets misreported. Both asks cover mail forwarded into those mailboxes, and the party in a position to satisfy it is the forwarder. If you run a forwarding service, a mailing list or a mail gateway, this is about you. If you send marketing or transactional mail from your own domain, it is not, and no configuration change on your side produces an ARC chain.

Receivers asking for ARC while the IETF retires it is less of a contradiction than it looks. The retirement draft itself allows receivers to keep verifying ARC for forensic purposes, and it advises against basing delivery decisions on chain validity alone; neither Apple nor Orange says how much weight a valid seal carries in its filtering. For a forwarder, that leaves two signals pointing different ways: the receivers ask for a seal today, and the IETF asks existing deployers to plan an exit. Sealing for receivers that request it is consistent with the first; treating a seal as a trust signal that should override DMARC is what the IETF says does not work.

The other three large mailbox providers ask for SPF, DKIM and DMARC, and none of them mention ARC. Across the domains we test for the Unspam 2026 Email Deliverability Benchmark, 48% publish a DMARC policy, which is the work that is genuinely unfinished.

What to do instead when forwarding breaks your DMARC

The problem ARC was built for is real and still needs handling. The available answers are less exotic.

  1. Make sure DKIM is aligned and signs the headers that survive. DKIM is the identifier that gets through a forward at all, because it covers the message rather than the connection. If only SPF is aligned, forwarding removes your only passing identifier.
  2. Keep the signed header list conservative. A signature over headers that intermediaries routinely rewrite breaks more often than one over the essentials.
  3. Read your DMARC reports before assuming forwarding is the cause. Forwarders show up as sources you do not recognize passing DKIM and failing SPF, which is a distinctive shape and easy to separate from real problems.
  4. Do not stay at p=none because of forwarding. Mail that passes aligned DKIM survives the forward, and the reports tell you which sources do not before you enforce anything.
  5. If you operate an intermediary, follow the DKIM2 work rather than building on ARC, and seal only where a receiver you deliver to, such as Apple or Orange, asks for it.

Our guide to DMARC records covers the policy and the reporting, and the identifier that forwarding breaks first is the subject of our guide to the Return-Path.

What a checker can report, and what it should refuse to report

An ARC chain in a message you received is evidence about its path, and it is worth reading on exactly those terms.

Our email header analyzer reports the chain structure: how many sets are present, whether the instance numbers form a continuous sequence from 1, whether each set is complete, whether the cv values follow the rule for their position, and the domain that sealed each hop. It reports a cv=fail as the point where the chain ended.

What it does not do is verify the signatures, and it does not tell you the chain is trustworthy. Those are different claims, and the draft is explicit that chain validity without a reputational judgment is not a basis for a delivery decision. A tool that prints a green ARC badge is asserting something no receiver would act on.

For the records that do decide delivery, our guide to email authentication covers how SPF, DKIM and DMARC depend on one another. To see the authentication results on a real message, including any ARC chain it picked up along the way, run a free spam test.

Frequently asked questions

What is ARC in email?

ARC, the Authenticated Received Chain, is a way for an intermediary such as a mailing list or a forwarding service to record the authentication results it saw when a message arrived, sign that record, and seal everything before it in the chain. A receiver at the end can then see the original result as the first hop observed it, even though forwarding has broken SPF and any modification has broken DKIM. It is defined by RFC 8617 as an experiment.

Do I need to set up ARC for my domain?

No. ARC is added by intermediaries relaying somebody else's message, so an originating sender has nothing to seal and there is no ARC record to publish on your domain. The headers appear only on mail that has been relayed. A guide telling an ordinary sending domain to enable ARC has confused it with DKIM. If you operate a forwarding service, a mailing list or a mail gateway, you are the party ARC was written for.

Is ARC being deprecated?

Yes, as a proposal. The IETF DMARC working group's draft-ietf-dmarc-arc-to-historic asks that RFC 8617 be reclassified as Historic and would obsolete it if approved. The first version was approved as a working group draft on 22 April 2026, and revision -01, with the same text, was posted on 21 October 2026. Its conclusions say the experiment is over, that operators should not rely on ARC going forward and should cease further Internet-wide deployments, and that new deployments are discouraged. The working group's charter milestone for requesting the status change is dated 30 November 2026, and no last call had been held as of 7 November 2026. Until a status change is approved, ARC remains an Experimental RFC.

Why is ARC being retired?

Not because the cryptography failed. Verifying a chain is necessary but not sufficient: an evaluator has to decide whether to trust each signer before acting on its assertions, which means running a reputation system for intermediaries, and after ten years nobody built one that works at Internet scale. What deployers built instead were allowlists of intermediaries they already trusted, which works bilaterally and does not generalize. ARC also identifies which intermediary modified a message but has no mechanism to say what changed or why. Receivers also never agreed on how many hops to honor or how to treat a broken chain, so the same message could be judged differently from one receiver to the next.

Does Apple require ARC?

Apple's sender requirements, published in February 2025, ask for ARC on mail forwarded to Apple mailboxes, and Apple is the only one of the four large mailbox providers to ask for it at all. Orange's postmaster page, updated on 1 September 2026, also strongly recommends ARC sealing for forwarded messages. The scope matters: both asks cover forwarded mail, and the party in a position to satisfy them is the forwarder. If you send from your own domain, no configuration change on your side produces an ARC chain.

What does a valid ARC chain look like?

Each hop adds three headers: ARC-Authentication-Results, ARC-Message-Signature and ARC-Seal. RFC 8617 section 5.2 requires the instance numbers to run continuously from 1 to at most 50 with no gaps and no repetition, exactly one of each header per instance, cv=none on the seal at instance 1 and cv=pass on every later one. A cv=fail at the highest instance ends the chain there. The structure is checkable offline; the signatures are not, and chain validity on its own is not a basis for a delivery decision.

Related articles

9 Black Friday 2026 Deals for Email Marketers, With Codes and Dates Spamhaus Sender Guidelines: the HELO and Reverse DNS Rule Spamhaus Delisting: Which List You Are On Decides the Route

See where your campaign actually lands.

Start a free spam test Inbox placement test